Pillow Shopper Guide - Mattress Nut Skip to content Mattress Nut Pillow Guide Mattress Guide Site Search Search for: Search Pillow Shopper Guide What challenge do you have with your current pillow? I'm new to Pillow Shopping My Pillow is Flat Pillow is Too Soft Pillow is Too Firm Pillow worsens Allergies Pillow doesn't Fit Covers/Bed If your pillows get flat too easily…high-density materials like gel foam and dense down will hold their shape better. Italian Plush Gel Pillow Medium Density Down Firm Plush Down See More Take a look at these pillows that tend to be firmer.Shredded memory foam is a favorite among people who prefer firmer pillows. Adjustable Shredded Memory Foam Plush Memory Foam Medium Plush, Firm Memory Foam See More Take a look at these pillows that tend to be softer.Down pillows compress more and are highly desirable for people who want softer pillows. Adjustable Firmness Shredded Foam 90/10 Soft Goose Down Soft-Medium Firm Luxury Down See More If you need more support and you are a side sleeper...try one of these pillows Shredded Memory Foam with Side Support Firm Memory Foam with Side Support Memory Foam Shoulder Pillow See More If you need more support and you are a back sleeper...try one of these Hollowfibre Support Pillow Half-Moon Booster with Memory Foam Fiberfill Extra-Firm Pillow See More If your allergies get worse when sleeping, it might be your pillow...here are some great hypoallergenic, mite-resistant pillows Hypoallergenic Bamboo and Shredded Memory Foam Dust Mite Resistant Gel Plush Hypoallergenic Memory Foam See More If you just need a great all-rounder pillow...try one of these highly rated pillows on Amazon Head and Neck support pillow Adjustable Memory Foam Bamboo and Memory Foam See More Disclosures This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.