by Quick answer: The Graco Olivia Crib is a well-reviewed, budget-friendly pick, but it ships without a mattress — put the money you saved into a quality crib mattress like the Saatva Crib Mattress instead.
- Manufactured by Storkcraft under exclusive license from Graco for the North American market, per the manufacturer's product documentation.
- Converts from crib to toddler bed to daybed, though the conversion guardrail kit is sold separately.
- GREENGUARD Gold certified and JPMA/ASTM-CPSIA compliant, with safety testing verified by the Baby Safety Alliance.
Updated July 2026 · Reviewed for accuracy
The Graco Olivia Crib earns strong marks from owners for being easy to assemble and sturdy once it's together. That's the good news. The part that catches people off guard is what's not in the box: no mattress, and no conversion guardrail kit for when your toddler outgrows the crib stage. Both are sold separately, and neither is optional if you actually want to use this crib the way it's marketed.
Below, I'll walk through what the Olivia actually is, what verified owners say after living with it, and — since a crib is only as good as what your kid sleeps on inside it — where to put your mattress budget once you've bought the frame.
What the Graco Olivia Crib Actually Is
The Olivia is a pine-wood, 3-in-1 convertible crib with an arched, classic silhouette — think traditional nursery furniture rather than a modern slat-and-metal look. It's built to convert from a standard crib into a toddler bed and eventually a daybed as your child grows, and it offers four mattress-height positions so you can lower the base as your baby starts pulling up to stand. Some retailers also list a version with a storage drawer built into the base, which is worth checking if nursery space is tight.
Here's the catch worth flagging twice: the crib converts to a toddler bed and daybed, but the guardrail kit needed for that conversion is sold separately, per Graco's own product listings. Cross-checking retailer inventory across Home Depot, Wayfair, and Amazon, that kit isn't always in stock, and verified owner photos on Wayfair show finish mismatches between the original crib wood and the conversion kit wood on some units. If you're buying the Olivia specifically because you want a crib that grows with your kid without buying new furniture later, confirm the conversion kit is actually available before you commit.
Certifications and Safety
On paper, the Olivia checks the boxes parents actually care about. It's GREENGUARD Gold certified, meaning it's been tested for low chemical emissions, and it meets JPMA and ASTM/CPSIA safety standards for crib construction. Graco also lists the crib as verified by the Baby Safety Alliance, an accredited lab that re-tests certified products annually rather than treating certification as a one-time checkbox.
That said, certification covers the crib structure — not the mattress. A crib mattress needs its own safety and material certifications, which is one more reason not to grab whatever's cheapest once you've spent your budget on the frame.
What Verified Owners Say
According to verified owner reviews on Wayfair, the Olivia holds a strong overall rating, with buyers consistently praising how straightforward it is to assemble and how solid the frame feels once it's built. The classic arched design also comes up repeatedly as a selling point for parents who want a traditional nursery look rather than a minimalist one.
The complaints are narrower but consistent. The most common one: the toddler-bed and daybed conversion kits are frequently out of stock, and when they do ship, the wood finish doesn't always match the original crib — which undercuts the "grows with your child" pitch that's central to a 3-in-1 design. A smaller number of verified reviews also flag an occasional manufacturing defect where the mattress support base's screw holes don't line up cleanly during assembly. Neither issue is universal, but both are worth knowing about before you buy, especially if seamless conversion down the line is part of why you picked a 3-in-1 crib in the first place.
Worth noting on the warranty front: Graco/Storkcraft backs the Olivia with a standard limited manufacturer's warranty rather than anything extended — reasonable for the price point, but not a reason to skimp on the mattress that goes inside it.
The Part That Trips People Up: No Mattress Included
Every crib sold today — the Olivia included — fits a standard-size full crib mattress, and none of them come with one. That's normal across the category, not a knock specifically on Graco. But it means your total nursery budget isn't just "the crib price." It's the crib plus a mattress your baby will actually sleep on for the next few years, through infancy and into the toddler bed stage if you use the conversion kit.
This is where I'd spend deliberately rather than defaulting to whatever's cheapest at checkout. A budget-friendly crib frame is a smart place to save. The mattress isn't — it's in direct contact with your baby every night, and it needs to meet real safety and support standards through more than one developmental stage.
The Saatva Crib Mattress is the one I point people toward for exactly this situation. It's a dual-sided hybrid: a firmer side for infants, which flips to a softer side once your child moves into toddler years, so it's designed to carry a family through the same crib-to-toddler-bed conversion the Olivia itself offers. It's GREENGUARD Gold certified, has an organic cotton cover, and includes a built-in waterproof barrier — and it's sized to fit any standard crib, including the Olivia.
If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Mattress Options for the Olivia Crib
If you're not sure which direction to go, here's how the two mattresses I'd actually consider for this crib stack up against each other.
| Feature | Saatva Crib Mattress | The Futon Shop Organic Crib Mattress |
|---|---|---|
| Design | Dual-sided hybrid — firmer infant side flips to a softer toddler side | Organic latex, wool, or coconut coir builds, depending on model |
| Certifications | GREENGUARD Gold certified | Organic-material and chemical-free focus |
| Cover | Organic cotton cover with a built-in waterproof barrier | Natural fiber covers, varies by model |
| Fit | Fits any standard crib, including the Olivia | Fits standard crib dimensions |
| Best for | Parents who want one mattress that adjusts as their child grows | Parents prioritizing organic and natural materials above all else |
If you want the flip-to-grow convenience that mirrors what the Olivia's own 3-in-1 conversion is trying to do, Saatva is the more direct match. If your priority is sourcing every material as close to natural as possible, The Futon Shop's organic crib mattress line is worth a look — they offer several organic builds at different price points depending on how far you want to go on materials.
Either way, don't assume a crib mattress and a Pack 'n Play mattress pad are interchangeable — they're built to different safety standards, and a crib needs a firm, properly fitted mattress of its own.
Conversion Kits and Long-Term Value
If the whole appeal of a 3-in-1 crib is that you buy once and convert as your child grows, the Olivia's conversion-kit availability issue matters more than it would on a straight fixed-side crib. Before you buy, it's worth checking current stock of the toddler bed and daybed rail kits directly with the retailer, since verified owner reports note they can be hard to find months after the crib itself ships. If a mismatched wood finish would bother you, that's a real consideration here rather than a hypothetical one.
On the mattress side, this is also where the "convertible" story matters. A dual-sided mattress like Saatva's, built to flip from an infant-firm side to a toddler-softer side, is designed around the exact same crib-to-toddler-bed transition the Olivia is selling — so the two purchases actually work together rather than requiring you to swap the mattress out entirely once your child moves to a toddler bed.
And when that day does eventually come to replace the mattress altogether — whether due to wear, a move, or a new baby — here's what to check before you do.
Is the Graco Olivia Crib Worth It?
Yes, with a caveat. As a crib frame, the Olivia is a legitimately good value: verified owners consistently rate it well for ease of assembly and sturdiness, and its certifications (GREENGUARD Gold, JPMA, ASTM/CPSIA, Baby Safety Alliance-verified) hold up to real scrutiny. Where it falls short is everything around the frame — a standard rather than extended warranty, and conversion kits that aren't always easy to find when you actually need them.
My take: buy the Olivia if the arched, classic look and the low frame cost are what you're after, and go in knowing the conversion kit availability is a real, verified issue rather than a rare complaint. Then don't cut corners on the one thing that touches your baby every night. Pair it with the Saatva Crib Mattress for a dual-sided design that grows alongside the crib's own conversion stages, or go with The Futon Shop's organic line if natural materials are your top priority.
Check current pricing on the Saatva Crib Mattress →
FAQ
Does the Graco Olivia Crib come with a mattress?
No. Like nearly every crib on the market, the Olivia is sold as a frame only. It fits a standard-size full crib mattress, which you'll need to purchase separately — the Saatva Crib Mattress is a strong fit given its dual-sided infant-to-toddler design.
Is the Graco Olivia Crib safety certified?
Yes. Per the manufacturer, it's GREENGUARD Gold certified for low chemical emissions and meets JPMA and ASTM/CPSIA safety standards. Graco also lists it as verified by the Baby Safety Alliance, an accredited lab that re-tests certified products on an annual basis.
Who actually manufactures the Graco Olivia Crib?
Storkcraft manufactures the Olivia under an exclusive license from Graco for the North American market, according to the manufacturer's product documentation. This is standard practice for the Graco crib line and doesn't affect the certifications or construction quality.
Can the Olivia Crib convert into a toddler bed?
Yes, it's designed as a 3-in-1 that converts from crib to toddler bed to daybed. The guardrail kit needed for that conversion is sold separately, and verified owner reports note it's not always in stock or perfectly matched in finish to the original crib — worth confirming availability before you buy if the conversion feature matters to you.
What's the biggest complaint about the Graco Olivia Crib?
Based on verified owner reviews, the two recurring issues are limited availability of the toddler-bed/daybed conversion kits (with occasional finish mismatches) and, less commonly, a manufacturing defect where the mattress support base's screw holes don't align cleanly during assembly. Overall satisfaction remains high despite these reports.
OUR VERDICT
Buy the Olivia for the frame value, but budget the mattress properly: the Saatva Crib’s dual-sided design outlasts the crib’s own warranty by years.
OUR CRIB MATTRESS PICK
Saatva Crib Mattress
- $359 , dual-sided: firmer infant side flips to a softer toddler side
- GREENGUARD Gold certified, organic cotton cover, waterproof barrier
- Fits any standard-size crib (52" x 28")
