by Quick answer: The Pottery Barn Kendall crib is a solid, heavy piece of nursery furniture at roughly $600-$800, but it ships with only a 30-day warranty and no replacement hardware program — spend the savings on a GREENGUARD Gold crib mattress like the Saatva Crib instead.
- Kendall Collection cribs run about $600 for the crib alone, about $800 with the toddler conversion rail, per potterybarnkids.com
- Every Kendall model is GREENGUARD Gold and Fair Trade Certified and CPSC-lab tested, but the written warranty covers only 30 days
- The crib mattress is sold separately — the Saatva Crib Mattress ($359, per saatva.com) is our pick to pair with it
Updated July 2026 · Reviewed for accuracy
I'll say this up front: the Pottery Barn Kendall crib is not a bad crib. It's heavy, it's well-built, and it carries a certification combination you don't see often. What it isn't is a good deal once you read the fine print on the warranty and the replacement parts situation. Here's what verified owner reviews, Consumer Reports, and Pottery Barn's own product pages actually say about it — and where I'd put my money instead.
What's Actually in the Kendall Collection Lineup
Pottery Barn Kids sells its cribs under the Craftsman-style Kendall Collection, and the lineup is bigger than most shoppers realize. There's the 4-in-1 Convertible, which is the brand's best-seller; a standard Convertible; an All Spindle version; a Low-Profile model that sits four inches lower than the standard crib; and the Grow With Me 6-in-1, which converts from a bassinet all the way through a full-size bed and bundles in the conversion kits, a mini mattress, and two sheet sets.
| Model | What it does | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Kendall 4-in-1 Convertible | Crib → toddler bed → daybed → full bed | Most shoppers (best-seller) |
| Kendall Convertible | Standard convertible crib | Simpler nurseries |
| Kendall All Spindle | Spindle-front design variant | Traditional nursery look |
| Kendall Low-Profile | Sits 4 inches lower than standard | Shorter parents, easier lifting |
| Grow With Me 6-in-1 | Bassinet → crib → toddler bed → daybed → full bed, with conversion kits, mini mattress, and 2 sheet sets included | Parents who want one piece from newborn on |
Every model in the collection offers three mattress-height positions (14.5, 19.5, and 24.5 inches), comes in six colorways, and has wheels you can remove once the crib is in its permanent spot.
Build Quality and Certifications
This is where the Kendall genuinely earns credit. Pottery Barn Kids builds it from solid New Zealand pine with LVL (laminated veneer lumber) components, and Consumer Reports notes the heavy-duty version uses solid poplar instead. Every crib in the line is GREENGUARD Gold Certified and Fair Trade Certified, and it's tested in a CPSC-accredited lab. Holding both certifications on the same crib is genuinely rare in this price tier — most competitors pick one or the other. Wirecutter's assembly notes clock the build at about 23 minutes, which lines up with what I'd expect from a crib this well-engineered.
The Warranty Problem Nobody Mentions
Here's the part that doesn't show up in the glossy product photos. According to verified owner reviews compiled by Leafscore — which previously recommended the Kendall and has since walked that recommendation back — the crib's written warranty covers just 30 days. Compare that to a piece of furniture that's meant to hold a sleeping child for two to three years, and 30 days starts to look thin.
The bigger issue is hardware. Owners report that when a bolt, cam lock, or bracket fails or goes missing, Pottery Barn Kids doesn't sell replacement hardware directly, the hardware format isn't a standard US size you can pick up at a hardware store, and the defective-parts replacement window is capped at one year. There's also the teething rail to consider — it's plastic, it isn't listed among the crib's stated materials, and it isn't sold as a replaceable part on its own. If it cracks or a corner comes loose, you're not swapping just that piece.
Pottery Barn Crib Pricing: What You're Really Paying
Per potterybarnkids.com, a Kendall crib alone runs about $600, and about $800 once you add the toddler conversion rail. Buying online adds roughly $50 in shipping, and white-glove delivery and assembly runs about $99 more. None of that includes a mattress or the conversion kits for later stages — those are sold separately, and Pottery Barn Kids doesn't bundle them into the base price except on the Grow With Me 6-in-1.
| Line item | Approximate cost |
|---|---|
| Kendall crib only | ~$600 |
| Kendall crib + toddler rail | ~$800 |
| Standard online shipping | +$50 |
| White-glove delivery/assembly | +$99 |
| Crib mattress | Sold separately |
Leafscore's comparison puts that in perspective: the Kendall runs roughly double the price of a DaVinci Kalani crib, and roughly five times an Ikea Sniglar, for a warranty that's shorter than either competitor's.
Why the Mattress Matters More Than the Crib
Pottery Barn Kids sells the Kendall as a frame — the mattress is a separate purchase no matter which model you pick. That's actually the smart place to spend the money you'd otherwise put toward white-glove delivery or a pricier conversion kit. If you already read our Naturepedic crib mattress review or our Avocado crib mattress review, you know GREENGUARD Gold certification on the mattress matters just as much as it does on the frame — arguably more, since it's what your child breathes against every night.
My pick to pair with a Kendall crib (or any standard-size crib) is the Saatva Crib Mattress. It's priced at $359 on saatva.com, it's dual-sided — a firmer surface for infants that flips to a softer side as your child grows into toddlerhood — and it's GREENGUARD Gold certified with an organic cotton cover and a built-in waterproof barrier. It fits any standard-size crib, including the Kendall's 52 x 28-inch interior, so there's no compatibility guesswork.
If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Saatva Crib Mattress vs. The Futon Shop Organic
If you want to go further on the natural-materials side, The Futon Shop's organic crib mattresses are worth a look. They're built from organic latex, wool, and coconut coir at several price points, with a chemical-free focus that goes beyond GREENGUARD Gold certification into fully natural fill materials.
| Saatva Crib Mattress | The Futon Shop Organic Crib Mattress | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $359 | Multiple price points |
| Design | Dual-sided (firm infant / softer toddler) | Organic latex, wool, coconut coir builds |
| Certification | GREENGUARD Gold | Chemical-free, organic materials focus |
| Cover | Organic cotton, waterproof barrier | Varies by build |
Both are worth pricing out on their own sites before you decide — see The Futon Shop's organic crib mattress lineup here. If your priority is dual-sided convenience as your baby grows, I'd lean Saatva. If your priority is going as natural as possible on fill materials, The Futon Shop's organic builds are the stronger fit.
How the Kendall Compares to DaVinci and Ikea
The certification stack is genuinely rare — GREENGUARD Gold plus Fair Trade on the same crib isn't something DaVinci or Ikea match at their price points. But per Leafscore's value analysis, you're paying roughly 2x a DaVinci Kalani and roughly 5x an Ikea Sniglar for that stack, and neither of those competitors ships with a warranty as short as 30 days. If certifications and a heavier, more furniture-grade build matter most to you, the Kendall's premium is defensible. If you're mainly optimizing for value and warranty coverage, it's a harder case to make.
Our Verdict
The Kendall is a good crib — solid wood, real certifications, quick to assemble. But I tend to recommend putting your budget where it does the most good: a well-built crib frame plus a mattress that's independently certified and easy to replace or upgrade later. The 30-day warranty and the hardware-replacement gap are real drawbacks that show up in verified owner complaints, not hypotheticals, so go in with your eyes open on those two points specifically.
For the mattress side of that equation, the Saatva Crib Mattress is the pairing I'd buy — it's $359, GREENGUARD Gold certified, and dual-sided so it grows with your child instead of needing a full replacement at the toddler stage.
And if the nursery is just one room on your list, our Pottery Barn living room ideas guide covers how to make the rest of the house look just as put-together without matching the nursery's price tag room by room.
FAQ
Does the Pottery Barn Kendall crib come with a mattress?
No. Pottery Barn Kids sells the crib as a standalone frame, and the mattress is purchased separately, along with any later-stage conversion kits.
How long is the Pottery Barn crib warranty?
According to verified owner reviews compiled by Leafscore, the written warranty on Pottery Barn Kids cribs covers 30 days, with a defective-parts replacement window capped at one year.
Can you buy replacement hardware for a Pottery Barn crib?
Owners report that Pottery Barn Kids does not sell replacement hardware directly and that the hardware isn't a standard US format, which makes sourcing a replacement bolt or bracket difficult if a piece is lost or fails.
Is the Pottery Barn Kendall crib GREENGUARD Gold certified?
Yes. Every model in the Kendall Collection is GREENGUARD Gold Certified and Fair Trade Certified, and it's tested in a CPSC-accredited lab, per potterybarnkids.com.
What crib mattress pairs well with a Pottery Barn crib?
Any standard-size crib mattress fits, since the Kendall uses a standard 52 x 28-inch interior. The Saatva Crib Mattress is a dual-sided, GREENGUARD Gold certified option at $359, and The Futon Shop's organic latex, wool, and coconut coir builds are a natural-materials alternative at several price points.
OUR VERDICT
The Kendall is furniture-grade and it shows , just know the warranty fine print. Whatever crib you pick, the dual-sided mattress inside it is the purchase that lasts.
OUR CRIB MATTRESS PICK
Saatva Crib Mattress
- $359 , dual-sided: firmer infant side flips to a softer toddler side
- GREENGUARD Gold certified, organic cotton cover, waterproof barrier
- Fits any standard-size crib (52" x 28")
