The Amerisleep AS3 wins this comparison for most sleepers. Its HIVE 5-zone support layer firms precisely under the lumbar while staying soft at the shoulders, which is something GhostBed Classic's unzoned foam construction cannot replicate. GhostBed Classic is a legitimate budget pick at $848 queen for stomach or back sleepers who want a firmer, bouncier surface and don't need deep pressure relief. Note that NapLab reports GhostBed has discontinued the Classic and replaced it with the GhostBed Comfort Foam, so stock may be limited.
Amerisleep AS3
9.1/10
- HIVE 5-zone support: softer at shoulders and hips, firmer at lumbar
- Bio-Pur open-cell foam rated 9/10 for cooling by NapLab
- CertiPUR-US certified, made in the USA
- 20-year warranty, twice the industry standard
- Softer edges than a coil hybrid
- Sleepers over 230 lb may prefer the AS3 Hybrid for added support
The AS3 is the better mattress for side sleepers and anyone with shoulder or hip pressure. Its HIVE zoned layer does real work. Amerisleep designs it to give more support under the head, back and legs and more cushioning under the shoulders and hips.
Amerisleep AS3 vs GhostBed Classic: how they actually compare
These two mattresses sit at opposite ends of the all-foam spectrum. The AS3 is a true contouring memory-foam bed with slow response, deep hug, and excellent motion isolation. The GhostBed Classic uses a perforated latex top layer over gel-infused memory foam, which makes it firmer, more responsive, and bouncier than the AS3 at a lower price.
Neither is a bad mattress. But they serve different sleepers, and the wrong pick will feel noticeably off within the first two weeks.
Side-by-side specs
| Mattress | Type | Firmness | Trial | Warranty | Queen price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amerisleep AS3 | All-foam (Bio-Pur) | Medium 5/10 | 365 nights | 20 years | $1,149 (queen) |
| GhostBed Classic | Combo foam (latex + gel) | Medium-Firm 6.5/10 | 365 nights | 20 years | ~$848 |
Construction breakdown
Amerisleep AS3 is 12 inches tall with three layers: a 3-inch Bio-Pur comfort layer on top, a 2-inch HIVE transition layer in the middle (the zoned support layer), and a 7-inch Bio-Core high-density base. The HIVE layer is the defining feature. Hexagonal foam cutouts create five distinct support zones across the body. Shoulders and hips get softer zones for pressure relief; the lumbar gets a firmer zone to prevent the reverse arch that causes lower-back pain.
GhostBed Classic is 11 inches tall with a perforated aerated latex top (1.5 inches), gel-infused memory foam middle (2 inches), and a high-density support foam base (7.5 inches). The perforated latex is what differentiates GhostBed: it's bouncier and more responsive than memory foam, runs slightly cooler due to the aerated structure, and gives the mattress a medium-firm rather than pure-medium feel. Total comfort layer is 3.5 inches, which is thinner than the AS3's 5-inch comfort stack.
Performance head-to-head
Pressure relief
The AS3 wins clearly here. Its slower-response Bio-Pur foam lets the shoulder and hip sink into the comfort layer while the HIVE support layer holds the lumbar. Side sleepers in particular will notice the difference. The GhostBed Classic's firmer latex surface does not give the same hip-relief on the side. NapLab gives the GhostBed Classic 9.0/10 for pressure relief and the AS3 10/10; with a 3.5-inch comfort layer, the GhostBed is at a disadvantage for heavier side pressure.
Cooling
The AS3 wins here, despite GhostBed's aerated latex top. NapLab recorded a maximum surface temperature of 92.7 degrees Fahrenheit on the GhostBed Classic, near the top of all the mattresses it has tested (8.0/10 for cooling), versus 85.4 degrees on the AS3 (9/10). Neither is as cool as a hybrid with a coil core.
Motion isolation
NapLab measured 4.80 m/s² of motion transfer on the GhostBed Classic (10/10) and just 2.11 m/s² on the AS3 (also 10/10). Both beds work well for couples. Slight edge to Amerisleep in pure motion deadening due to the slower-response Bio-Pur foam.
Feel and responsiveness
This is the biggest practical difference. The AS3 has the slow-melt memory foam feel: you sink in, and the foam holds you there. Combination sleepers who switch positions frequently find the AS3 a little slow to respond. The GhostBed Classic is the opposite. Latex bounces back almost instantly, making position changes easy. If you share the bed and both of you move during the night, GhostBed's responsiveness is noticeably more comfortable. If you sleep on your side in one position all night, the AS3's pressure relief is more valuable.
Edge support
Both beds are all-foam, and all-foam beds have softer edges than coil hybrids. Neither wins this category. Both give noticeable compression when sitting on the perimeter: NapLab measured 4.50 inches on the GhostBed Classic (8.6/10) and 5.5 inches on the AS3 (8.0/10). GhostBed is slightly more stable at the edge, but not enough to be a deciding factor.
Trial and warranty
GhostBed Classic lists a 365-night trial (as listed by NapLab), the same length as the AS3's 365 nights. Both carry 20-year warranties. Amerisleep's warranty is split: full replacement in years 1 through 10, and prorated replacement in years 11 through 20. GhostBed's warranty covers sagging over 1 inch and manufacturing defects across the 20 years. For long-term protection the structure is similar; for trial confidence GhostBed gives you more runway.
Price
GhostBed Classic is meaningfully cheaper at approximately $848 queen versus the AS3 at approximately $1,149 queen. That $401 gap is real money. For side sleepers who need the HIVE zoning, the AS3 is worth the premium. For back or stomach sleepers who want a responsive foam bed and do not sleep hot, GhostBed delivers solid value.
Who should choose which
Choose the Amerisleep AS3 if: you sleep primarily on your side, you have shoulder or hip pressure-point issues, you share the bed and need motion isolation, or you want the 20-year warranty with HIVE zoned pressure relief.
Choose GhostBed Classic if: you sleep on your back or stomach and prefer a firmer 6.5/10 surface, responsiveness matters more than deep contouring, you want a longer 365-night trial, or budget is the deciding factor at $848 queen.
For most sleepers, especially side sleepers and those with back pain, the Amerisleep AS3 is the better-engineered mattress. Its HIVE 5-zone support layer does something GhostBed's construction cannot. GhostBed Classic is a legitimate budget alternative for back and stomach sleepers who want bounce, firmness, and a long trial window.
GhostBed Classic
8.1/10
- Aerated latex top layer adds bounce and responsiveness
- Perfect motion isolation score (10/10, NapLab)
- 365-night trial, over 3 times longer than AS3
- Approximately $401 cheaper than the AS3 for a queen
- Medium-firm 6.5/10 is too firm for most side sleepers
- Thinner 3.5-inch comfort layer limits pressure relief depth
- No zoned support, and NapLab measured it among the warmest beds it has tested
GhostBed Classic is the right call if your priority is bounce, firmness, a long trial, and a lower price. For pressure-relief-focused sleepers, the AS3 is still the better pick.
Frequently asked questions
Is Amerisleep AS3 or GhostBed Classic better for side sleepers?
Amerisleep AS3. Its HIVE zoned support layer provides softer zones at the shoulder and hip while firming under the lumbar. GhostBed Classic runs at 6.5/10 firmness with an unzoned foam stack, and most side sleepers will feel too much resistance at the shoulder and hip.
Which mattress runs cooler, Amerisleep AS3 or GhostBed Classic?
The Amerisleep AS3. NapLab recorded a maximum surface temperature of 85.4°F on the AS3 (9/10) versus 92.7°F on the GhostBed Classic (8.0/10), despite GhostBed's aerated latex top. Both are foam beds, so if cooling is your top priority, a coil hybrid will still sleep cooler.
How does GhostBed Classic's 365-night trial compare to Amerisleep's 365 nights?
GhostBed's trial is substantially longer. 365 nights is the AS3's full trial, and Amerisleep refunds returns made after the first 30 nights. 365 nights gives you a full year to decide, which removes most of the purchase risk. For buyers who are uncertain, GhostBed's trial is a genuine advantage.
Are both mattresses comparable in durability?
Both carry 20-year warranties, which signals above-average durability. Amerisleep's Bio-Pur foam is designed for longevity. The warranty splits into full replacement (years 1 through 10) and prorated replacement (years 11 through 20). GhostBed's latex top layer is inherently durable material, but the gel-infused memory foam underneath follows standard foam lifecycle expectations.
Amerisleep AS3
9.1/10
Medium 5/10 feel, HIVE 5-zone support, Bio-Pur plant-based memory foam, CertiPUR-US certified, 365-night trial, 20-year warranty. The more versatile and better-engineered mattress of the two, especially if you sleep on your side or need lumbar zoning.