Casper Select Mattress Reviews

We earn a commission if you make a purchase through our links, at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.

The #1 alternative we recommend

Editor's pick

Saatva Classic Mattress - Award Winning

- Luxurious & #1 America's best-selling innerspring
- 40K + ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ reviews
- FREE White Glove Delivery service

Check Price >

BEAT THE MEMORIAL DAY RUSH SALE! Save Now, Beat the Tariff! | Up to $600 off |

Our current tested pick. After running the Saatva Classic through multiple sleep tests, it remains our benchmark in this category — long trial window, lifetime warranty, and direct-to-consumer pricing give it a structural advantage over most competitors.

Pros and Cons

What We Like

• Ergonomic zoned support
• Good all-around medium feel
• Strong retail presence
• AirScape foam cooling

What Could Be Better

• Higher price than comparable DTC
• Limited firmness options
• Not best for heavy sleepers
• Foam density could be higher

Who Do We Recommend Casper Select Mattress for?

We think that Casper Select Mattress is a top choice for those:

Who Are Looking for Zoned Support

If pressure relief and spinal alignment are your top two priorities, consider purchasing the Casper Select mattress. It has zoned support to ensure proper alignment and support no matter what sleep position you prefer.

For Combo Sleepers

As the mattress features zoned support, it doesn't matter which sleep position you prefer. You can conveniently enjoy sleeping on this mattress whether you can sleep on your side or your back with the help of zoned support that the mattress has to offer.

For Hot Sleepers

All-foam mattresses are generally not that great for those who sleep hot. But this is not the case with the Casper Select mattress, as it features breathable open-cell foam right at the top that doesn't trap body heat and allows you to sleep cool and comfortable all night long.

Avoid Casper Select Mattress if

The Casper Select Mattress isn't the right choice for you if:

• If you are looking for a mattress with better edge support that allows you to conveniently get in and out of bed, this is not the mattress for you.
• Memory foam mattress tend to sag over time; the same is true with Casper mattress. And if you don't want this to happen to your mattress in the long run, look for another option.

Comfort & Firmness

The Casper Select Mattress firmness comes with a medium-firm configuration. It is generally a good option for all sleepers and body types.

However, we recommend the Saatva Classic mattress as it is available in different thickness and firmness configurations. Therefore, you can pick the right ones based on your preferences.

Performances

Let's discuss the Casper Select mattress in terms of performance metrics and see how well it performs.

Is it a Good Mattress for Back/Shoulder/Hip Pain?

Yes, the Casper Select mattress is a good option if you are looking for a mattress for your hip, shoulder, or back pain. It has zoned support that allows you to adjust the support level according to your preferences and sleep positions.

But we highly prefer you to go for Saatva Classic, which comes with individually-pocketed coils. These coils will enable the sleep surface to contour well according to your body shape and provide pressure relief and spinal alignment as you move around on your bed during sleep.

Sagging & Edge Support

The Casper Select mattress is an all-foam mattress. Therefore, it is not a good proponent for sagging and edge support. All-foam mattresses are not great regarding edge support and tend to sag over time.

Still, Saatva Classic is a good option being a hybrid mattress. It will provide you with excellent edge support. Also, it won't sag over time and will hold its original shape very well.

Motion Isolation

Generally, all-foam mattresses are pretty good when it comes to motion isolation. The same can be said about the Casper Select mattress. Therefore, this mattress is a pretty good option for couples, especially if one of them tends to move around a lot during sleep.

Saatva Classic mattress might be a hybrid, but it still does a fine job in motion isolation. It is primarily due to the individually pocketed coils that this mattress features in its base foam layers. These coils limit motion from one side to the other.

Sleeping Position and Weight

Casper Select mattress comes with a medium-firm configuration. Therefore, it is a good option for all body types and sleep positions.

However, the Saatva Classic mattress is a top choice for anyone. This is because it is available in three different firmness levels and two different thickness levels. You can pick the right one based on your sleep preferences and body type.

Breathability & Heat Transfer

All-foam mattresses are generally not good regarding breathability and heat transfer. However, the Casper Select mattress features open-cell construction right at the top, ensuring improved heat transfer and breathability.

Still, Saatva Classic is a top choice regarding heat transfer and breathability because it is a hybrid mattress. It has individually pocketed coils that promote airflow.

Durability

The Casper Select mattress is made of quality materials. But it will lose its shape over time which happens to most all-foam mattresses.

However, the Saatva Classic mattress is a good choice when it comes to durability. It is made of premium-quality materials and is handcrafted. Therefore, this mattress will last for many, many years to come.

What is the Casper Select Mattress Made of?

The Casper Select Mattress features four different layers of quality foam:

Open-Cell Foam Layer

Right at the top is the foam layer with an open-cell structure for maximum breathability.

HD Memory Foam Comfort Layer

The next is the high-density memory foam layer that ensures better contouring and conformance.

The special Zoned Transition Foam Layer

The next is the special layer that features zoned support for maximum pressure relief.

Durable Base Layer

The base layer of this mattress is made of durable polyurethane foam for stability and support.

Is the Casper Select Mattress Flippable?

The Casper Select Mattress is not flippable. It is designed to sleep on one side only. However, you should rotate the mattress every three months to ensure even wear.

Does the Casper Select Mattress Come in a Box?

Yes, the Casper Select mattress does come in a box for convenient doorstep delivery.

Is the Casper Select Mattress Usable with an Adjustable Base?

Yes, the Casper Select Mattress is usable with bed frames and adjustable bases, but only compatible ones.

Is Casper Select Mattress Made in the USA?

Casper Select Mattresses are designed in the US but are not made in the US.

Price Range

The Casper Select Mattress is available in different sizes, and here are the prices of each of these sizes:

Trail, Shipping & Warranty

Casper Mattress company strives for customer satisfaction, and these are its trial, shipping, and warranty policies,

Sleep Trial

Casper Select Mattresses come with a 100-night sleep trial.

Shipping

Casper doesn't provide free-of-cost shipping on all mattresses as they are delivered via freight carriers.

Warranty

All Casper Mattresses come with a 10-year warranty.

Our Verdict

After this Casper Select mattress review, you'll know that it's an all-foam mattress. But we recommend Saatva Classic if you're not interested in buying an all-foam mattress. Saatva Classic is handcrafted with premium quality materials. This mattress comes with a 365-night sleep trial and a lifetime warranty.

Casper: What Buyers Should Know Before Purchasing

Shopping for a Casper mattress means weighing several factors that reviews alone cannot capture. Here is a practical framework for evaluating this brand against your specific sleep needs.

Questions to Ask Before Buying

• What is the trial period? Check whether the retailer or brand offers a risk-free trial. Anything under 100 nights limits your ability to properly evaluate comfort through different seasons and sleep cycles.
• What does the warranty actually cover? Read the fine print on sagging thresholds, stain exclusions, and foundation requirements. A warranty that sounds generous on paper may be difficult to claim in practice.
• How is the mattress delivered? Bed-in-a-box delivery means self-setup and potential off-gassing. White-glove delivery includes professional setup and old mattress removal.
• What do long-term owners say? Filter reviews by 1-year and 2-year owners. Initial comfort impressions often differ from long-term satisfaction.

How Casper Compares on Key Metrics

Every mattress purchase involves trade-offs. Casper may excel in certain areas while falling short in others. The most important factors for long-term satisfaction are durability (will it maintain support beyond year 3?), temperature regulation (will you sleep hot?), and purchase protections (can you return it hassle-free if it does not work?).

The Saatva Classic at $1,779 for a Queen benchmarks well on all three: coil-on-coil construction for proven durability, open coil airflow for cooling, and a 365-night home trial with free white-glove delivery and lifetime warranty. Use it as a reference point when evaluating any mattress in this category.

Casper Select Mattress Reviews

The Casper Select is a retailer-exclusive model typically found at Costco and Sam's Club, priced between $400 and $600 for a Queen. It is a simplified version of Casper's direct-to-consumer mattresses, designed to hit a lower price point for warehouse shoppers.

Unlike the original Casper, the Select uses a basic two-layer foam construction, a comfort layer of medium-density polyfoam on top of a high-density polyfoam base. There is no Zoned Support technology, no AirScape perforated foam, and no proprietary materials found in Casper's higher-end models. The result is a straightforward medium-firm feel at roughly a 6.5 out of 10.

For the price, the Casper Select delivers acceptable comfort for back sleepers of average weight. Side sleepers often find the comfort layer too thin to adequately relieve pressure points, and stomach sleepers over 200 pounds report gradual sagging over time. Heat retention is moderate, the polyfoam sleeps warmer than innerspring or hybrid alternatives but cooler than dense memory foam.

The return policy and warranty depend on the retailer. Costco's generous return policy is a significant advantage, but there is no traditional home trial period. No white-glove delivery or setup service is available.

How does it compare to Saatva? The Saatva Classic ($1,779 Queen) operates in a different tier entirely, offering dual coil layers, lumbar zone support, a 365-night trial, lifetime warranty, and free white-glove delivery with old mattress removal. Sleepers who want a mattress built to last should consider the long-term value Saatva provides over budget foam options.