by The Casper Select is a warehouse-exclusive all-foam mattress (Costco, Sam's Club) priced around $400 to $600 for a Queen. It delivers a serviceable medium-firm feel for average-weight back sleepers, but its basic two-layer construction lacks the zoned support and durability of Casper's direct-to-consumer lineup. For a step up in quality and purchase protections, the Saatva Classic is our top recommendation: dual coil layers, three firmness options, a 365-night trial, and a lifetime warranty with free white-glove delivery.
Saatva Classic
9.2/10
- Dual coil-on-coil construction with reinforced lumbar zone pad
- Organic cotton Euro pillow top, GREENGUARD Gold certified
- Free white-glove delivery: in-room setup and old mattress removal
- 365-night home trial and lifetime warranty
- Three firmness levels (Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, Firm) and two heights
- Heavier than compressed bed-in-a-box options, ships flat
- $99 return shipping fee during the trial period
If you are considering the Casper Select but want meaningfully better durability, support, and purchase protections, the Saatva Classic is the natural step up. It benchmarks well on every metric where budget foam mattresses fall short: coil longevity, temperature regulation, and a long trial that actually lets you test the mattress properly.
Casper Select: what it is and who sells it
The Casper Select is not sold on Casper's website. It is a retailer-exclusive model distributed through warehouse clubs, primarily Costco and Sam's Club, and is priced well below Casper's direct-to-consumer lineup, typically $400 to $600 for a Queen depending on the retailer and season.
The positioning is straightforward: Casper's brand recognition at a warehouse price point. The trade-off is a simplified construction that strips out most of what distinguishes Casper's flagship models, including Zoned Support, AirScape perforated foam, and the multi-layer comfort system found in the Casper Original or Wave Hybrid.
What you get is a basic two-layer all-foam mattress: a comfort layer of medium-density polyfoam on top of a high-density polyfoam base. Total height is approximately 10 to 12 inches depending on the batch. The result is a medium-firm feel, roughly 6.5 out of 10, that works adequately for back sleepers of average weight (150 to 200 lb) but shows clear limitations in other scenarios.
Construction and materials
The Casper Select uses a simplified foam stack with four functional layers:
Open-cell top foam
The uppermost layer uses an open-cell polyfoam structure intended to improve airflow. It reduces the worst heat-trapping behavior of dense closed-cell foam, though it does not match the cooling performance of innerspring or hybrid designs where air circulates freely through coil gaps.
Memory foam comfort layer
Below the top foam sits a thinner memory foam comfort layer. This layer is responsible for the body-contouring feel but, at its thickness, provides limited pressure relief for side sleepers whose hips and shoulders need deeper cushioning.
Zoned transition foam
A transition layer positioned between the comfort system and the base provides differentiated firmness across body zones. This is the Select's most meaningful design feature, offering some support differentiation between the lumbar and shoulder zones. That said, the zoning is less precise and less effective than the zoned coil systems found in mid-range hybrids.
High-density polyfoam base
The base layer is a standard high-density polyfoam core that provides the foundational support and structural stability of the mattress. It is a reliable, durable base material, though it does not respond to weight the way a pocketed coil core does.
Firmness and feel
The Casper Select lands at roughly 6 to 6.5 out of 10 on a standard firmness scale, placing it in medium-firm territory. That range works well for back sleepers in the 130 to 200 lb range, who tend to find adequate lumbar support without uncomfortable pressure on the spine.
Side sleepers are more mixed. Lighter side sleepers (under 130 lb) generally find the medium-firm feel comfortable. Side sleepers in the 150 to 200 lb range report that the comfort layer is too thin to relieve hip and shoulder pressure adequately, especially as the mattress breaks in over time. Heavy side sleepers over 230 lb consistently report insufficient pressure relief and gradual sagging in the hip zone.
Stomach sleepers fare reasonably well in the short term due to the firmer feel, though the foam base can allow the pelvis to sink slightly, which creates lumbar extension stress for heavier stomach sleepers over time.
Performance
Cooling and temperature
The open-cell top foam moderates heat retention better than dense closed-cell memory foam, putting the Casper Select in the middle of the foam range. It will sleep warmer than a hybrid or innerspring mattress where coil airflow is built into the design. Hot sleepers who run warm at night will likely notice this.
Motion isolation
All-foam construction absorbs motion effectively. Couples where one partner moves at night will generally be satisfied with the Casper Select's motion isolation, which is better than most hybrid or innerspring alternatives. This is the area where all-foam mattresses hold a clear advantage.
Edge support
Edge support is where foam-only mattresses typically fall short, and the Casper Select follows that pattern. The perimeter compresses noticeably under weight, which makes sitting on the edge to put on shoes or getting in and out of bed less stable than a coil-edge reinforced hybrid. Couples who sleep near the edge of the mattress may feel they are working with a smaller usable sleep surface.
Durability
Polyfoam at standard densities softens more quickly than high-density memory foam or pocketed coils. Long-term owner reviews of the Casper Select from Costco and Sam's Club report visible body impressions by year two to three of consistent use. This is faster softening than mid-range hybrids and significantly faster than a coil-on-coil construction like the Saatva Classic. If longevity matters, this is the most meaningful limitation of the Casper Select versus a higher-investment mattress.
That said, the flip side of the price point is the risk-reward. At $400 to $500 for a Queen, even five years of use produces a reasonable cost-per-year figure. Costco's generous return policy provides an additional safety net that the mattress's lack of a formal home trial does not.
Adjustable base compatibility
The Casper Select is compatible with adjustable bed bases, as foam mattresses flex without damage. If you already own an adjustable base or plan to buy one, the Select will work with it. However, all-foam mattresses paired with adjustable bases add heat retention that can be a factor in warm climates or for hot sleepers.
Pricing and sizes
Pricing depends on the retailer. Typical Costco and Sam's Club pricing in 2025 to 2026:
| Size | Dimensions | Approx. price |
|---|---|---|
| Full | 54 x 74 in | ~$350 to $500 |
| Queen | 60 x 80 in | ~$400 to $600 |
| King / Cal King | 76 x 80 in | ~$550 to $700 |
Pricing fluctuates with seasonal warehouse promotions. There is no consistent online pricing or formal MSRP.
Trial, shipping, and warranty
Sleep trial
There is no traditional home trial period for the Casper Select. Because it is sold through warehouse clubs rather than Casper directly, Casper's 100-night trial does not apply. Costco's own return policy is generous and covers mattresses with a full refund in most cases, which functions as a practical trial, but the terms and timeframe vary by location and member status.
Shipping
The Casper Select ships compressed in a box for in-home delivery. No white-glove delivery or setup service is available. Old mattress removal is not included.
Warranty
Casper Select mattresses are typically covered by a 10-year warranty through Casper, though warranty claims on retailer-exclusive models can be more complex to navigate than direct purchases. Keep your receipt and document the purchase date.
Who should buy the Casper Select
- Back sleepers at average weight (130 to 200 lb) who want an accessible all-foam feel and are comfortable with the Costco purchase experience.
- Budget-conscious shoppers who want a named brand at warehouse pricing and plan to replace the mattress in three to five years.
- Light side sleepers under 130 lb who find firm surfaces uncomfortable but do not need deep pressure relief.
- Couples with one active sleeper who prioritize motion isolation above other performance factors.
Who should look elsewhere
- Side sleepers over 150 lb: the comfort layer will not provide sufficient pressure relief at the hips and shoulders long-term.
- Heavy sleepers over 230 lb: the base foam will soften and sag faster under consistent heavy load, reducing support over time.
- Hot sleepers: all-foam construction retains more heat than a hybrid or innerspring design.
- Anyone prioritizing edge support: the perimeter compression is a genuine limitation for couples and for getting in and out of bed.
- Buyers who want a long trial period: the absence of Casper's direct trial means less protection if the mattress is not the right fit.
Casper Select vs. Saatva Classic
The Casper Select and the Saatva Classic ($1,095 to $2,400 Queen depending on size and firmness) address different parts of the market, but they are compared often because shoppers weighing a budget foam purchase want to know when a higher-investment mattress justifies the price difference.
The Saatva Classic uses a dual coil-on-coil construction: tempered steel individually wrapped pocketed coils in the comfort zone sitting on top of a continuous-coil support core, with a reinforced lumbar zone and an organic cotton Euro pillow top. It ships with free white-glove delivery, includes old mattress removal, and backs the purchase with a 365-night home trial and a lifetime warranty.
The construction differences produce measurable performance gaps. The Saatva Classic's coil system allows airflow that reduces heat retention significantly below the Casper Select's all-foam construction. Edge support is noticeably better. Long-term durability of tempered coils outlasts standard polyfoam. For sleepers who plan to keep a mattress for eight to ten years, the Saatva Classic's lifetime warranty and coil construction represent a structural advantage that compounds over time.
The Casper Select's advantages are its lower upfront price and its motion isolation. For short-term use, a tight budget, or a guest bedroom situation, the Casper Select is a reasonable choice. For a primary sleep surface where longevity and support matter, the Saatva Classic holds the stronger case.
The Casper Select is a sensible warehouse buy for back sleepers at average weight who want a named brand at a budget price. Its weaknesses, limited pressure relief for side sleepers, faster foam softening, and modest edge support, become significant for shoppers with specific needs or a long time horizon. The Saatva Classic is our top recommendation for anyone who wants materially better support, cooling, trial protection, and long-term value.
Frequently asked questions
Where is the Casper Select sold?
The Casper Select is a warehouse-exclusive model sold primarily through Costco and Sam's Club. It is not available on the Casper website or through other mattress retailers, and pricing varies by warehouse promotion.
Does the Casper Select come with a sleep trial?
No. Because it is sold through warehouse clubs rather than directly by Casper, the Casper Select does not include Casper's standard 100-night home trial. Costco's return policy is generous and provides a practical alternative, but terms depend on your local warehouse and membership status.
Is the Casper Select good for side sleepers?
It is adequate for lighter side sleepers under 130 lb but falls short for most side sleepers in the 150 to 230 lb range. The comfort layer is not thick enough to relieve hip and shoulder pressure over time, and heavier side sleepers report body impressions forming within two to three years. A medium mattress with deeper cushioning or a hybrid with zoned support will serve side sleepers better.
How does the Casper Select compare to the regular Casper mattress?
The regular Casper Original includes Casper's Zoned Support system, AirScape perforated foam for cooling, and a more refined multi-layer comfort system. It also ships with a 100-night home trial directly from Casper. The Select strips those features to reach the warehouse price point. The Original is a better mattress with better purchase protections, though it costs more.
Is the Casper Select flippable?
No. Like most modern foam mattresses, the Casper Select is one-sided with a defined sleeping surface and a non-sleeping base. Rotating it 180 degrees every three to six months is recommended to even out wear, but flipping is not designed into the construction.
Saatva Classic
9.2/10
If the Casper Select's limitations give you pause, the Saatva Classic is the clearest upgrade path: dual coil construction, three firmness options, a 365-night trial, lifetime warranty, and free white-glove delivery with old mattress removal. It outperforms budget foam on every long-term metric that matters.