Old Tempurpedic Mattress Models Reviews

We earn a commission if you make a purchase through our links, at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.

Discover Our #1 Top-Rated Mattress Alternative

Editor's pick

Saatva Classic Mattress - Award Winning

- Luxurious & #1 America's best-selling innerspring
- 40K + ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ reviews
- FREE White Glove Delivery service

Check Price >

BEAT THE MEMORIAL DAY RUSH SALE! Save Now, Beat the Tariff! | Up to $600 off |

Our current tested pick. After running the Saatva Classic through multiple sleep tests, it remains our benchmark in this category — long trial window, lifetime warranty, and direct-to-consumer pricing give it a structural advantage over most competitors.

Pros and Cons

What We Like

• Premium memory foam relief
• Excellent motion isolation
• Wide model range
• Decades of research

What Could Be Better

• Significantly more expensive
• Can sleep hot
• Heavy and hard to move
• Slow response time

Comparison Table

#1 – Grand Cloud Plush

Saatva Classic mattress is, of course, the better option here. The Saatva Classic offers a coil-on-coil innerspring design that provides excellent support, addressing the sagging issue.

It also features eco-friendly materials, strong edge support, and a range of comfort options. The Saatva Classic is a durable, comfortable, and supportive mattress that outshines the Grand Cloud Plush in several key aspects.

Comfort & firmness:

The Grand Cloud Plush mattress by Tempur-Pedic is designed to provide a soft, plush comfort level. It combines quality memory foam with an innerspring system to offer a luxurious sleeping surface. The plush feel can be comfortable for those who prefer a softer sleep.

Sagging and edge support:

Unfortunately, the Grand Cloud Plush mattress is known to have issues with sagging over time. The lack of strong edge support can make it feel unstable when sitting or sleeping near the edge.

Motion isolation:

One of the advantages of memory foam is its ability to isolate motion, and the Grand Cloud Plush does a reasonable job in this regard. It can help reduce disturbances from a restless partner.

Sleeping position and weight:

The suitability of this mattress may vary depending on your sleeping position and body weight. It may offer better comfort for back and side sleepers who prefer a softer surface. Heavier individuals might experience more pronounced sagging.

Breathability & heat transfer:

Memory foam mattresses, including the Grand Cloud Plush, tend to retain heat. This may not be the best choice if you're prone to overheating during the night.

Durability:

Durability can be a concern with the Grand Cloud Plush due to its tendency to sag over time. If you're looking for a mattress that will last, you may want to consider other options.

#2 – DeluxeBed

This is a hybrid, and we'll talk about its features in more detail, but we recommend considering the Saatva Classic mattress for a more reliable choice. Saatva Classic's coil-on-coil innerspring design provides excellent support while addressing sagging concerns.

It also offers eco-friendly materials, strong edge support, and various comfort options to suit your preferences. The Saatva Classic is a durable and supportive mattress that may offer a better overall sleep experience than the DeluxeBed.

Comfort & firmness:

The DeluxeBed mattress offers a medium comfort level, making it suitable for a wide range of sleepers. With a combination of gel, memory foam, and poly foam layered on top of a spring system, it aims to provide a balanced and comfortable sleeping surface.

Sagging and edge support:

Similar to some hybrid mattresses, the DeluxeBed may be susceptible to sagging over time. However, it compensates for this by offering better-than-average edge support, making it more stable when sitting or sleeping near the edges.

Motion isolation:

The inclusion of memory foam in the DeluxeBed's construction can help with motion isolation. It should perform reasonably well in minimizing disturbances caused by a restless partner.

Sleeping position and weight:

This mattress's medium comfort level should accommodate various sleeping positions, including back, side, and stomach sleepers. However, individual preferences may vary based on body weight, with heavier individuals potentially experiencing more sagging.

Breathability & heat transfer:

The gel infusion in the DeluxeBed's construction may assist with heat dissipation, but memory foam mattresses generally retain heat. If you tend to sleep hot, you may want to consider this factor.

Durability:

Like many mattresses, the DeluxeBed may experience some sagging over time. While it offers better edge support, the long-term durability might still be a concern.

#3 – Contour Rhapsody Breeze

While the Contour Rhapsody Breeze offers good durability and firm support, we recommend exploring the Saatva Classic mattress for a more versatile choice.

The Saatva Classic combines a coil-on-coil innerspring system with various comfort options, ensuring excellent support without sacrificing comfort.

It also provides strong edge support and is suitable for a wide range of sleepers. The Saatva Classic offers a balanced sleep experience that may appeal to a broader audience compared to the Contour Rhapsody Breeze.

Comfort & firmness:

The Contour Rhapsody Breeze mattress by Tempur-Pedic offers a firm configuration level, making it well-suited for those who prefer a firmer sleeping surface. It primarily features high-quality memory foam to provide support and comfort.

Sagging and edge support:

One of the notable advantages of the Contour Rhapsody Breeze is its resistance to sagging. The durable memory foam construction maintains its shape over time. Additionally, it offers better-than-average edge support, ensuring stability when sitting or sleeping near the edges.

Motion isolation:

Memory foam excels in motion isolation, and this mattress is no exception. It effectively minimizes motion transfer, making it a good choice for couples or individuals who are easily disturbed by movement.

Sleeping position and weight:

The firm configuration of this mattress makes it suitable for back and stomach sleepers who require support to maintain proper spinal alignment. However, it may not provide the desired level of cushioning for side sleepers.

Breathability & heat transfer:

While the Contour Rhapsody Breeze may have some cooling properties, traditional memory foam mattresses can still retain heat. If you tend to sleep hot, this may be a consideration.

Durability:

This mattress is known for its durability, as it is designed to resist sagging and maintain its shape over time. It is a long-lasting option in the Tempur-Pedic lineup.

#4 – Bellafina

For a well-rounded and luxurious mattress option, we suggest considering the Saatva Classic mattress. The Saatva Classic combines a coil-on-coil innerspring system with various comfort levels, ensuring excellent support and comfort.

It offers strong edge support and is suitable for a wide range of sleepers, including combination and side sleepers. The Saatva Classic provides a comfortable and supportive sleep experience that may surpass the Bellafina in terms of versatility and overall quality.

Comfort & firmness:

The Bellafina mattress offers a medium configuration level, making it a versatile choice for those who prefer a balanced level of comfort and support. It primarily features quality memory foam to enhance the overall sleep experience.

Sagging and edge support:

One of the strengths of the Bellafina mattress is its resistance to sagging. The durable memory foam construction helps it maintain its shape over time. While it offers decent edge support, it may not be as strong in this aspect as some other models.

Motion isolation:

With its memory foam composition, the Bellafina mattress excels in motion isolation. It effectively minimizes motion transfer, which can be especially beneficial for couples.

Sleeping position and weight:

The medium configuration of this mattress makes it suitable for combination sleepers and side sleepers who need a balance of comfort and support. It can provide the necessary cushioning for side sleepers while maintaining support for other sleeping positions.

Breathability & heat transfer:

Like many memory foam mattresses, the Bellafina may have some cooling features, but it's important to consider that traditional memory foam can retain heat. If heat dissipation is a concern, you may want to explore cooling mattress options.

Durability:

The Bellafina is considered a fairly durable model thanks to its resistance to sagging. It is designed to maintain its structural integrity over an extended period.

Price Range

Trial, Shipping & Warranty

Here are the trial, shipping and warranty options that came with these mattresses.

Trial: These mattresses used to come with a 90-night sleep trial.

Warranty: They were covered under a 10-year warranty

Shipping: Different shipping options were available from different stores.

Our Verdict

While Tempur-Pedic has offered a range of mattress models, including the Grand Cloud Plush, DeluxeBed, Contour Rhapsody Breeze, and Bellafina, each with its unique features, there are considerations to bear in mind.

These Tempur-Pedic mattresses may exhibit sagging issues over time, varying edge support, and potential heat retention due to their memory foam components. For those seeking a more reliable and versatile mattress choice, we recommend the Saatva Classic.

The Saatva Classic combines a coil-on-coil innerspring system with different comfort options, delivering excellent support, durability, and cooling properties. It outshines these Tempur-Pedic models, offering a superior overall sleep experience.

Classic Tempur-Pedic Models: How They Compare to Current Lineup

If you bought a Tempur-Pedic 5–15 years ago, here is what you had and how the current models compare.

Legacy Models vs Current Equivalents

When to Replace Your Classic Tempur-Pedic

Tempur-Pedic mattresses typically last 7–10 years. Signs of expiration: visible body impression deeper than 1 inch, foam that no longer rebounds when you press it, or increased morning stiffness.

If your Tempur-Pedic is aging, see our guides on breaking in a new Tempur-Pedic and rotation schedule. Also check general mattress lifespan data.

For a comparable feel without the $3,000+ price tag, the Saatva Classic provides responsive support with better airflow at roughly half the cost, plus a 365-night trial vs Tempur-Pedic's 90.