by Brooklyn Bedding Alternatives: Amerisleep AS3 and Saatva Classic Compared (2026)
If your Brooklyn Bedding mattress is sagging, two strong replacements stand out: the Amerisleep AS3 for all-foam pressure relief and the Saatva Classic for innerspring support with white-glove delivery.
The Amerisleep AS3 is the replacement to look at first if your Brooklyn Bedding mattress is sagging. It is a medium-feel all-foam bed built to balance support and softness for every sleep position, backed by a 100-night trial, a 20-year warranty, and free shipping and returns. If you prefer an innerspring feel with a longer home trial and in-home setup, the Saatva Classic is the runner-up, with a 365-night trial, a lifetime warranty, and free white-glove delivery that includes old-mattress removal.
Amerisleep AS3
A medium-feel all-foam bed.
Saatva Classic
- Three comfort levels: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm
- Two height options to match your bed frame
- 365-night home trial gives you a full year to decide
- Lifetime warranty covers the mattress for as long as you own it
- Free white-glove delivery includes setup and old-mattress removal
- Innerspring construction may not suit sleepers who want a pure foam feel
- White-glove delivery scheduling requires someone to be home
The Saatva Classic is the pick for anyone who wants an innerspring mattress with a long trial and hands-off delivery. Choosing between three comfort levels and two heights lets you match the bed to how firm you like to sleep, and the white-glove crew handles setup and takes your old mattress away.
Brooklyn Bedding alternatives: key specs
| Spec | Amerisleep AS3 | Saatva Classic |
|---|---|---|
| Construction | All-foam (Bio-Pur) | Innerspring |
| Feel | Medium | Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, or Firm |
| Height options | – | Two heights |
| Trial | 100 nights | 365 nights |
| Warranty | 20 years | Lifetime |
| Shipping | Free shipping and returns | Free white-glove delivery with old-mattress removal |
Construction and materials
Brooklyn Bedding's Signature Hybrid is built around a coil system with high-density foam and premium steel coils assembled in-house. The comfort layer uses ThermoPhase foam, which is infused with phase change material designed to absorb and release heat, and a pressure-relieving quilt foam that adapts to the shape of your body. The encased coil system and sturdy base are designed to provide motion isolation and edge support across the full surface of the mattress. Brooklyn Bedding offers the Signature Hybrid in three comfort levels: soft, medium, and firm, with an optional cooling pillow top available.
The Amerisleep AS3 takes a different approach. It is an all-foam mattress built with Bio-Pur foam, and Amerisleep describes it as a medium-feel bed designed to balance support and softness for every sleep position. Without coils, the AS3 relies entirely on its foam layers for contouring and support.
The Saatva Classic is an innerspring mattress offered in three comfort levels (Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm) and two heights. That combination of choices is the main structural difference between it and a fixed-firmness foam bed.
Feel and firmness
The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid comes in soft, medium, and firm versions, so you can pick the feel that matches how you sleep. The Amerisleep AS3 has a single medium feel rather than a firmness you have to choose up front.
The Saatva Classic gives you three firmness options: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm, plus two height choices. If you already know you want a specific firmness rather than a medium compromise, Saatva's lineup gives you a say in the matter.
Pressure relief
Pressure relief is where the construction differences show up most clearly. Brooklyn Bedding's Signature Hybrid uses a pressure-relieving quilt foam designed to adapt to your body's shape and reduce pressure points, working alongside the coil system underneath. The Amerisleep AS3 is an all-foam mattress, so pressure relief comes from foam contouring with no coils at contact points. The Saatva Classic is an innerspring mattress: its Plush Soft comfort level gives the most give at the shoulders and hips, while Firm keeps you on top of the surface.
Cooling
Brooklyn Bedding addresses temperature with ThermoPhase foam, a layer infused with phase change material that absorbs and releases heat to help maintain a comfortable sleep temperature. An optional GlacioTex cooling cover and Cloud Cooling Pillow Top are also available. The Amerisleep AS3 uses Bio-Pur foam in its construction. The Saatva Classic's innerspring design allows more airflow through the mattress than a solid foam build.
Motion isolation
Brooklyn Bedding specifically designs the Signature Hybrid's encased coil system and base for superior motion isolation, which matters if you share a bed. All-foam mattresses like the Amerisleep AS3 have no coils to transfer movement across the surface. Innerspring mattresses like the Saatva Classic allow movement to travel through the coils, so light sleepers with a restless partner should weigh that trade-off.
Trial period and warranty
Brooklyn Bedding backs the Signature Hybrid with a 365-night trial and a limited lifetime warranty, plus free shipping. The Amerisleep AS3 comes with a 100-night trial and a 20-year warranty, with free shipping and returns included.
The Saatva Classic matches Brooklyn Bedding's 365-night home trial and offers a lifetime warranty. Its delivery model is the differentiator: free white-glove delivery means the mattress is brought into your home, set up, and your old mattress is removed for you. That is a different experience from a bed-in-a-box shipment arriving at your door.
Price and value
We do not list prices on this page. What we can say is how the value propositions differ. Brooklyn Bedding positions the Signature Hybrid as factory-direct, and its own page notes the mattress ships in 5 to 8 business days. The Amerisleep AS3 includes free shipping and returns with a 20-year warranty. The Saatva Classic bundles white-glove delivery and old-mattress removal into the purchase. Compare the full package, not just the sticker price, when you are replacing a bed.
Who should buy each mattress
Buy the Amerisleep AS3 if: you want an all-foam mattress with a medium feel, you prefer foam contouring over coils, or you want a straightforward bed-in-a-box replacement with free shipping and returns, a 100-night trial, and a 20-year warranty.
Buy the Saatva Classic if: you want an innerspring mattress with three comfort levels and two heights to choose from, you value a 365-night home trial and a lifetime warranty, or you would rather have the mattress delivered, set up, and your old one hauled away than deal with a rolled bed and disposal on your own.
If your Brooklyn Bedding mattress is sagging, the Amerisleep AS3 is the first alternative to consider: a medium-feel all-foam bed with a 100-night trial, a 20-year warranty, and free shipping and returns. The Saatva Classic is the runner-up for sleepers who want coils, three firmness choices, a 365-night trial, a lifetime warranty, and white-glove delivery with old-mattress removal. Pick the AS3 for foam contouring and the Saatva for innerspring support with full-service delivery.
Frequently asked questions
My Brooklyn Bedding mattress is sagging. What should I replace it with?
The Amerisleep AS3 is the first replacement to consider. It is a medium-feel all-foam mattress built to balance support and softness for every sleep position, and it comes with a 100-night trial, a 20-year warranty, and free shipping and returns. If you want an innerspring mattress instead, the Saatva Classic offers three comfort levels, two heights, a 365-night trial, a lifetime warranty, and free white-glove delivery that includes removing your old mattress.
Is the Amerisleep AS3 or Saatva Classic better for side sleepers?
Side sleepers who want foam contouring at the shoulder and hip may prefer an all-foam build like the Amerisleep AS3. Side sleepers who want to choose their own firmness rather than accept a single medium feel can pick the Plush Soft version of the Saatva Classic.
Which sleeps cooler, the AS3 or the Saatva Classic?
The Saatva Classic's innerspring construction allows more airflow through the mattress than a solid foam build like the Amerisleep AS3. If you sleep hot and want maximum air circulation, coils move more air than foam. If you prefer the feel of foam but want cooling features, Brooklyn Bedding's own ThermoPhase foam and optional cooling cover are the features to look at on that side of the comparison.
How long can I try these mattresses at home?
The Amerisleep AS3 comes with a 100-night trial. The Saatva Classic comes with a 365-night home trial. Brooklyn Bedding's Signature Hybrid also offers a 365-night trial. All three give you a window to decide, but the lengths differ significantly.
Who removes my old sagging mattress?
Saatva includes old-mattress removal as part of its free white-glove delivery, so the delivery team takes your old bed with them when they set up the new one. With the Amerisleep AS3, you get free shipping and returns on the new mattress, but old-mattress removal is not part of the delivery service, so you will need to arrange disposal yourself.