by Broyhill by Sealy is one of the budget-friendly American brands which is quite famous among all-foam mattress lovers. This 14-inch and 86 lbs. mattress looks nice on a flatbed base and has sustainable materials that are healthy to sleep on. The knit cover has cool-to-the-touch, breathable fibers that don’t retain extra body heat. However, the whole mattress has polyurethane and polyester, which can be a health concern for people with sensitive skin.
However, we recommend Saatva’s Loom and Leaf over Broyhill mattresses because of their superior build, healthy materials, better ergonomics, and best-in-class after-sales services. With Loom and Leaf, you can choose a variety of bed foundations (even an adjustable bed). Moreover, the company offers two firmness levels according to your preference and weight. All these features make it the best alternative to Broyhill by Sealy Mattress.
The Broyhill by Sealy is a budget all-foam mattress sold exclusively at Big Lots for around $579 queen. It works for lightweight side and back sleepers on a tight budget. If you need something with a longer trial, a real warranty, and better long-term durability, our top alternative is the Amerisleep AS3 at a noticeably higher price but with a 100-night trial and 20-year warranty included.
Broyhill by Sealy (Big Lots)
5.8/10
- Budget price around $579 for a queen
- 14-inch profile looks substantial on a flatbed base
- CertiPUR-US certified foam layers
- SealyChill cover offers some breathability
- Comes in a box for easier delivery
ComfortSense Premium Memory Foam distributes body weight reasonably well
- Queen-only, no other size options
- No standard sleep trial, returns not available after purchase
- 5-year Allstate plan covers less than a real manufacturer warranty
- Prone to sagging for sleepers over 230 lb
- Polyurethane and polyester construction, no organic or plant-based materials
- No dedicated edge support system
The Broyhill by Sealy fills a real gap as a budget in-store mattress, but the no-trial policy and short protection window make it a risky buy unless you can test it in the store beforehand.
Who is Broyhill by Sealy, really?
Broyhill is a heritage American furniture brand founded in 1926, but the mattresses sold under that name at Big Lots are not manufactured by the original furniture company. The Broyhill name is licensed to a mattress manufacturer that produces budget-tier products using it. This is common in the bedding industry, but it means the quality reflects the licensee, not the Broyhill furniture heritage. Sealy handles the actual manufacturing here.
This matters because shoppers often assume the Broyhill name carries the same quality as the furniture line. Evaluate it on its own specs: foam density, certifications, and warranty terms. Not the name on the tag.
Construction and materials
Inside the Broyhill by Sealy, from top to bottom:
- SealyChill knit cover: cool-to-the-touch fibers designed to wick away surface heat. Works for mild hot sleepers on a budget.
- ComfortSense Premium Memory Foam: the primary comfort layer, conforms to the body and distributes weight across the surface.
- SealyCushion Gel Foam: a transitional layer that adds cushion and keeps the comfort foam from bottoming out too quickly.
- SealySupport Gel Foam: the base layer, providing structural support and protecting the shape of the mattress over time.
All foam layers carry CertiPUR-US certification, which covers emission levels, foam content, and durability standards. That is a meaningful baseline for a mattress at this price point. The main material concern is the polyurethane and polyester construction throughout, which can be an issue for sleepers with sensitive skin or chemical sensitivities.
Comfort and firmness
The Broyhill by Sealy sits at medium-plush firmness, which in our testing lands around a 4 to 5 out of 10. That makes it comfortable for side sleepers and lighter back sleepers who need contouring without the rigidity of a firmer foam. The ComfortSense and SealyCushion layers work together to create a dual comfort zone, distributing weight across the surface rather than letting pressure concentrate at the hips and shoulders.
In our testing, the medium-plush feel held up well for sleepers under 180 lb. Above that, the foam compresses enough to reduce the contouring effect and raise the risk of premature sagging. For sleepers over 230 lb, this mattress is not the right fit, as the foam core lacks the density to support heavier body weights long-term.
Performance
Motion isolation
The all-foam construction absorbs movement reasonably well. Couples where one partner moves more than the other will notice less transfer than on a spring mattress at this price. Memory foam at the medium-plush level handles motion isolation better than budget innersprings, and the Broyhill benefits from this.
Edge support
There is no dedicated edge support system inside the Broyhill by Sealy. The dense foam base provides some structure at the perimeter, enough to sit on the edge without immediately sinking through, but not enough to use the full surface as a sleeping area without feeling the drop. For couples who use the entire mattress width, this is a notable limitation.
Sagging and durability
The biggest long-term risk with the Broyhill is premature sagging. Budget foam at medium-plush firmness compresses faster than higher-density alternatives. The 5-year Allstate Protection Plan (available for $69.99 extra) covers accidental damage and manufacturing defects, but it does not carry the same weight as a manufacturer's warranty from a brand with a track record. Rotate the mattress every 3 to 6 months to extend its lifespan.
Breathability
The SealyChill cover provides a measurably cooler surface feel than a standard knit cover. For mild hot sleepers, this is a genuine plus. The all-foam construction underneath does retain some heat, as foam naturally does, but the cover offsets this more than most budget competitors in the same price range.
Sizing and price
The Broyhill by Sealy comes in queen size only, at 14 inches tall and 86 lb. The price is approximately $579 at Big Lots. There are no other size options, which eliminates it for anyone needing a twin, full, king, or California king. The mattress ships in a box and can be picked up in-store or delivered for free.
Trial, warranty, and returns
This is the most important thing to understand before buying:
- No sleep trial: Broyhill by Sealy has no standard trial period. Once you use it, returns are generally not available.
- Allstate Protection Plan: for $69.99, you get a 5-year protection plan covering accidental stains and manufacturing defects. This is an add-on product, not a manufacturer's warranty.
- Free delivery: in-store pickup or free home delivery available through Big Lots.
The absence of a sleep trial is a significant buyer risk. With a 14-inch all-foam mattress at medium-plush, you need time on it to confirm the firmness works for your body. Buying without a trial means relying entirely on the in-store feel.
Adjustable bed compatibility
The Broyhill by Sealy is compatible with adjustable bases. The all-foam construction flexes with the base position, making it a workable pairing if you already own an adjustable bed frame. For a dedicated adjustable base upgrade, see our best adjustable bed for back pain guide.
Is Broyhill mattress made in the USA?
Yes, the Broyhill by Sealy is manufactured in the United States and meets US quality standards. Sealy is an American company with domestic production facilities.
| Spec | Broyhill by Sealy | Amerisleep AS3 (our top pick) |
|---|---|---|
| Price (queen) | $579 | From $1,049 |
| Type | All-foam | All-foam (Bio-Pur, plant-based) |
| Firmness | Medium-plush ~4-5/10 | Medium 5/10 |
| Height | 14 in | 12 in |
| Trial | None | 100 nights |
| Warranty | 5-yr Allstate add-on | 20 years |
| Certifications | CertiPUR-US | CertiPUR-US, Bio-Pur plant-based foam |
| Available sizes | Queen only | Twin through Split King |
Who should buy Broyhill by Sealy
- Budget-first shoppers who need a queen mattress under $600 and can test it in a Big Lots store first.
- Lightweight side and back sleepers (under 180 lb) who prefer a medium-plush feel.
- Sleepers upgrading from a very old innerspring and just need basic foam contouring.
Who should skip it
- Anyone who needs a size other than queen, there are no other options.
- Sleepers over 230 lb, the foam is not dense enough for sustained support.
- Anyone who wants a sleep trial before committing, this mattress has none.
- Stomach sleepers who need a firmer core to maintain lumbar alignment.
- Anyone with sensitive skin or chemical sensitivities, the polyurethane and polyester construction may be a concern.
The Broyhill by Sealy is a reasonable budget foam mattress for lightweight side and back sleepers who can test it in-store and do not need a sleep trial. The $579 price is genuinely competitive. The no-trial policy and short protection window are real risks. For anyone who wants a trial window and a proper warranty, the Amerisleep AS3 below is the stronger long-term investment.
Our recommended alternative: Amerisleep AS3
If the Broyhill's no-trial policy concerns you, or you want a mattress that will hold up better beyond the 5-year mark, the Amerisleep AS3 is our top pick in the all-foam category. It costs more, but that gap buys a 100-night trial, a 20-year warranty, and a materially better foam construction.
Amerisleep AS3
9.1/10
- HIVE 5-zone support firms under the lumbar, softer at shoulders and legs
- Bio-Pur partially plant-based foam runs cooler than standard memory foam
- CertiPUR-US certified, made in the USA
- 100-night risk-free trial, full refund if you return it
- Available in all sizes, not just queen
- Price premium over budget options like the Broyhill
- Softer edges than a hybrid mattress
- Sleepers over 230 lb may find the AS5 Hybrid a better fit
For the same medium feel as the Broyhill but with a proper 100-night trial, 20-year warranty, and better foam density, the AS3 is the upgrade most Broyhill shoppers should consider when budget allows. The trial removes all the risk the Broyhill's no-return policy creates.
Frequently asked questions
Where can you buy the Broyhill mattress?
Big Lots is the primary retailer for Broyhill by Sealy mattresses. Some online retailers carry them, but availability varies. If you cannot find one at a Big Lots near you, the mattress may not be available in your area.
Is there a trial period for Broyhill mattresses?
No. The Broyhill by Sealy sold at Big Lots does not include a standard sleep trial. This is the most important thing to understand before purchasing. If the firmness does not work for you, returning it is generally not possible once you have used it. Test it in the store if at all possible.
Is Broyhill mattress good for back pain?
The medium-plush foam distributes body weight across the surface, which provides some pressure relief for back sleepers. However, the lack of dedicated lumbar support zoning means it is not specifically engineered for back pain. For a mattress with active lumbar support, consider the Amerisleep AS3 with its HIVE 5-zone system.
Can you flip a Broyhill mattress?
No, the Broyhill by Sealy is not a flippable mattress. It has a defined top and bottom layer. You can rotate it 180 degrees every 3 to 6 months to even out wear and extend its lifespan, but do not flip it.
What warranty does the Broyhill mattress have?
The Broyhill by Sealy does not include a standard manufacturer's warranty in the base price. A 5-year Allstate Protection Plan is available as a $69.99 add-on, covering accidental stains and manufacturing defects. This is not the same as a brand-backed warranty from the mattress manufacturer.
For related reading: best mattresses for back pain | best mattresses for lightweight sleepers | how long a mattress should last.